Hardwood Floor Refinishing vs. Screen and Recoat: Which Do You Need?
Savannah Premium Wood Flooring has been installing, repairing, and refinishing wood floors in the Savannah, GA area for over 20 years! Homeowners researching hardwood floor restoration quickly run into two options that sound similar but are not the same job at different price points: full refinishing and a screen and recoat. Choosing the wrong one costs more in the long run — either paying for a full sand when a recoat would have done the job, or applying a recoat over a floor that needed sanding and watching it fail within months. The distinction comes down to the condition of the existing finish and the depth of the damage the floor has sustained.
Why Choose Us
Unmatched Craftsmanship
We use top-grade hardwood and proven installation methods to deliver flawless, long-lasting floors that elevate any Savannah property.
Hardwood Floor Experts
Our team understands Savannah’s climate, design trends, and building standards, ensuring every floor performs beautifully in both modern and classic spaces.
Clean, On-Time, and
Customer-Focused
From consultation to final walkthrough, we provide clear communication, dust-controlled work areas, and on-schedule project completion with results that exceed expectations.
Get a FREE Estimate
What Is a Screen and Recoat?
A screen and recoat — sometimes called a buff and recoat — is a maintenance service, not a restoration service. The process uses a floor buffer with a screening pad to lightly abrade the surface of the existing finish, creating mechanical adhesion for a new topcoat. No wood is removed. The screening scratches the finish surface at a microscopic level so the new finish coat bonds rather than peeling. One to two fresh coats of polyurethane are then applied over the screened surface. The result is a floor with a renewed, uniform sheen that is more resistant to wear than the previous dull or scratched finish. A screen and recoat takes one day, costs significantly less than full refinishing, and produces no sanding dust. It is the right service when the floor's finish is worn, dull, or showing minor surface scratches that have not penetrated through the finish layer into the wood. It will not fix scratches in the wood itself, staining, discoloration, or finish adhesion failures — and applying a recoat over any of those conditions produces a result that fails quickly.
What Is Full Refinishing?
Full refinishing removes the existing finish entirely through drum sanding, exposing bare wood across the full floor surface. Once the floor is sanded to a clean, uniform surface, stain is applied if requested and multiple finish coats are built up from scratch. Full refinishing addresses damage that has penetrated the finish layer into the wood — deep scratches, oxidation staining, water marks, pet stains limited to the surface of the wood, and finish that has failed at the adhesion layer and cannot accept a recoat. It also allows the homeowner to change stain color, which a screen and recoat does not. Full refinishing removes a measurable amount of the wear layer with each sand, which is why tracking how many times a floor has been previously refinished matters. Most 3/4-inch solid hardwood floors support three to five full refinishes over their lifespan before the wear layer approaches the tongue.
How to Tell Which One Your Floor Needs
The simplest field test is to scratch the floor surface lightly with your fingernail in a worn area. If the scratch shows white — meaning you are scratching through a finish layer that has become cloudy or compromised — the finish is failing and a recoat may not bond correctly. If the area is simply dull rather than scratched, a screen and recoat is likely appropriate. Water drop test: place a few drops of water on the floor surface in a worn area and watch what happens. If the water beads, the finish is still intact and a screen and recoat is a viable option. If the water absorbs into the wood within a few minutes, the finish has worn through in that area and the floor needs at minimum a targeted repair before any recoat is applied. Floors with visible scratches in the wood, staining, or patchy areas where the finish has peeled or chipped always require full refinishing rather than a screen and recoat.
Get an Honest Assessment from
Savannah Premium Wood Flooring
The right service for your floor depends on its specific condition — not on which option is easier to schedule or less expensive upfront. Savannah Premium Wood Flooring assesses finish condition, wear layer depth, and damage type before recommending either service, and we will tell you directly if a screen and recoat is all your floor actually needs. We serve homeowners throughout Savannah including the Historic District, Victorian District, Ardsley Park, Thomas Square, Isle of Hope, Pooler, Richmond Hill, and Rincon. Contact us for a free on-site estimate.